Recent Posts

Shape is the first decision most people make and the one they change most often.

A diamond looks entirely different on a screen, on a display finger and on the hand it will actually live on, and almost nobody predicts which they will love until all three have happened. What follows is how we work through it at our Mt Hawthorn bench, in the order the decisions matter.

Shape Is Not The Same As Cut

These two words get used interchangeably and they are not the same thing.

Shape is the outline: round, oval, emerald, pear. Cut is how well the stone has been proportioned and finished, which governs how much light it returns. A poorly cut oval is a worse stone than a superbly cut round of the same weight, every time.

Here is the part almost nobody is told. GIA only issues a cut grade for round brilliants. Every fancy shape comes back with polish and symmetry grades but no overall cut grade, so you are relying on a jeweller’s eye rather than a letter. Our diamond cut guide covers what to look for.

The Main Diamond Shapes

Eight shapes account for most of what we set.

  • Round brilliant. 58 facets, engineered to maximise light return. The most popular shape worldwide. Also the dearest per carat, because cutting a round discards the most rough.
  • Oval. A brilliant cut in an elongated outline. Reads larger per carat and lengthens the finger. Currently the most requested shape through our door.
  • Emerald. A step cut with long open facets. Broad flashes rather than sparkle, and it shows colour and inclusions more readily. See our emerald cut guide.
  • Princess. Square, brilliant faceted, bright and modern. Sharp corners are the trade-off.
  • Cushion. Rounded corners and larger facets. Softer, more vintage sparkle, and forgiving to wear.
  • Pear. Brilliant faceted, rounded at one end and pointed at the other. Elongating, distinctive, and the point needs protecting.
  • Marquise. Two pointed ends and the most finger coverage per carat. Best value on the list for visible size.
  • Radiant. An emerald outline with brilliant faceting and cropped corners. Geometry with fire, covered in our radiant cut guide.

All eight come in natural and lab grown diamonds, and lab grown buys more size within a shape.

Where These Shapes Came From

A short detour, because the history explains the behaviour.

The round brilliant is the only shape that was engineered rather than evolved. In 1919 a Belgian mathematician named Marcel Tolkowsky calculated the proportions that would return the most light from a diamond and published them, effectively inventing the modern round. Every round since is a variation on that arithmetic, which is why the shape performs so predictably and why it is the only one GIA will grade.

The emerald cut was not designed for diamonds at all. Emeralds are brittle and cleave easily, so cutters cropped the corners to stop chipping during setting and used broad step facets to show colour rather than sparkle. Applied to diamond, that geometry yields the glassy, architectural look people either love on sight or find too quiet.

The marquise has the most romantic origin and the least verifiable. It is said to have been commissioned by Louis XV, its outline echoing the smile of the Marquise de Pompadour. True or not, it has carried her name for two hundred and fifty years.

Match The Shape To The Hand

The step people skip, and it changes the answer more than anything else.

Elongated shapes lengthen the visible line of the finger. They flatter shorter or wider fingers and read larger than a round of identical weight, because more of the stone sits face up. Square and round shapes sit compactly and hold proportion across a broad knuckle.

We keep loose stones in matched carat weights so this can be tested. A one carat oval beside a one carat round is only obviously different side by side on the same hand. Photographs never show it, and a display finger is not your finger.

One thing to watch in elongated brilliant cuts. Ovals, pears and marquises carry a bow-tie, a dark band across the centre caused by light being blocked at certain angles. All of them have some. Faint is normal, strong is a defect you should not pay for, and it is only visible face up in person.

Match The Shape To Your Life

Points and corners are where diamonds chip.

Pear and marquise have points, princess has four sharp corners. All can be worn daily and all need a setting that shelters the vulnerable part, usually a v-claw or a bezel. Round and cushion have no exposed points, making them the most snag-resistant of the group.

This matters more here than in most Australian cities. Between trades, hospitality, nursing and fly in fly out rosters, a large share of the hands we design for do serious work. If yours is one of them, we will steer you toward rounded shapes and lower settings first.

Shape, Carat And Budget

Shape affects price considerably, and not in the direction most people assume.

Round brilliants cost the most per carat, because producing one discards more rough than any other shape. Fancy shapes preserve more and price accordingly, so at identical colour, clarity and weight an oval or emerald costs meaningfully less.

Combine that with the size illusion and it compounds. An elongated shape reads larger per carat and costs less per carat, which is why the same budget produces a visibly bigger ring simply by moving off round. Our guide to what an engagement ring costs has the numbers.

Shape And Setting

The setting is built around the shape, not chosen from a catalogue afterwards.

A round or cushion is content in almost anything. Pear and marquise need protection at the point. Emerald and Asscher suit four-claw and bezel settings that honour their clean lines and look wrong crowded with detail. Elongated shapes work beautifully east-west, set horizontally across the finger.

Metal shifts the reading too. White gold and platinum keep a shape crisp. Yellow and rose gold warm it and forgive a lower colour grade, freeing budget for size.

Frequently Asked Questions

The five we are asked most often.

What Is The Best Diamond Shape?

There is no universal answer. Round returns the most light, oval balances size and sparkle, emerald offers the cleanest lines. The best shape suits the hand and the life it is going onto.

Which Diamond Shape Looks Biggest?

Marquise, then pear and oval. Elongated shapes spread more surface area face up, so they read larger than a round of the same weight.

Which Shapes Are Cheapest?

Fancy shapes generally cost less per carat than rounds, because cutting a round discards more of the rough crystal.

Do Fancy Shapes Get A Cut Grade?

Not from GIA. Only round brilliants receive an overall cut grade. Fancy shapes are graded for polish and symmetry, which is why comparing two in person matters.

What Is A Bow-Tie?

A dark band across the centre of an elongated brilliant cut, caused by light being blocked at certain angles. Every oval, pear and marquise has one to some degree. Faint is fine. Strong is not.

Come And Compare Them On The Hand

The honest advice is that you cannot choose a shape from a screen.

Come to our Mt Hawthorn studio and we will lay loose stones out in matched weights so you can see how each shape sits on the hand the ring is for, check for bow-ties face up, and judge the size illusion yourself.

Most people arrive with a shape in mind and about a third leave with a different one. A woman came in last winter certain she wanted an emerald cut, had been certain for two years, and had the screenshots to prove it. We put an oval beside it out of habit. She looked at one, then the other, then at her partner, and said quietly and slightly annoyed with herself that she had been wrong the whole time. She wears the oval. That is why we keep stones here rather than ordering them in afterwards.

Look through the custom gallery or start shaping something with the bespoke ring builder first.

Book a consultation and bring the hand that matters.